P1) If God were to exist then that being would be all powerful all knowing, and all good (all PKG) P2) If an all PKG being existed then there would be no evil. P3) There is evil C) Hence there is no God. P1) P ---> q P2) q ---> r P3) ~r --------------------------------------------------------- derived Conclusion ~q Conclusion ~p qG??????p ?††???? For this paper I am going to discuss Sobers schenatization of the argument from …showed first 75 words of 1053 total…

…showed last 75 words of 1053 total…creatures? I think it is clear that the evil that took place during these events were by far in excess of what was needed to teach us whatever we learned from them. Evils like these and many more humans endure every day ad I think it is ridiculously obvious that soul building evil can not account for all of it. Therefore I think the soul building criticisms does not disprove Sober's argument in the least.